[KongchangAI]
· 1 min read· 977 words

Is Moore's Law a Hoax or a Prophecy? An ASML Physicist Sets the Record Straight

Is Moore's Law a Hoax or a Prophecy? An ASML Physicist Sets the Record Straight

An ASML physicist calls Moore's Law marketing—essentially a self-fulfilling prophecy formed by collective supply-chain promises.

Based on expert views from The Vergecast, the article argues that Moore's Law is not a physical law but a self-fulfilling prophecy formed by collective industry promises. An ASML physicist bluntly calls it "marketing," resonating with insiders because the slogan holds technical expectations hostage and creates unrealistic schedule pressure. Moore's Law's persistence depends on interlocking trust and pressure across the supply chain; if one link can't deliver, the prophecy fails. The article suggests practitioners acknowledge its marketing component while understanding its practical role in coordinating a complex supply chain.

When an ASML Physicist Says "I Couldn't Care Less About Moore's Law"

In the tech industry, Moore's Law is almost as ubiquitous as air—computing power doubles roughly every two years. But is this decades-old "law" really as unshakable as it seems?

On an episode of The Vergecast, a physicist who has long worked at ASML offered a rather blunt assessment: "Moore's Law? I don't care about it at all. Moore's Law is for people who've never actually been in the trenches—it's just marketing."

Harsh as it sounds, this points to a fact that's tacitly accepted inside the industry but rarely discussed openly: Moore's Law's status as an "iron law" may be over-mythologized.

ASML physicist's comments on Moore's Law

ASML (Advanced Semiconductor Materials Lithography) is the world's only manufacturer of extreme ultraviolet (EUV) lithography machines, which are essential for producing advanced-node chips at 7nm and below. A single EUV machine contains more than 100,000 components sourced from thousands of suppliers worldwide, and each unit sells for over $150 million. ASML's physicists and engineers grapple directly with extreme engineering challenges—optical systems, light source power, mirror precision—and their aversion to the simplified "doubles every two years" narrative stems precisely from the physical limits and engineering complexity they encounter in their daily work.

The Essence of Moore's Law: A Collective Promise, Not a Physical Law

The podcast guest offered a more accurate description: Moore's Law is more like a "collective hallucination"—and that hallucination has become a self-fulfilling prophecy.

How does it work in practice? A group of people in the industry sit in the same room and map out a roadmap for the next 15 years. Everyone commits: "I can build this thing that doesn't exist yet—and may never exist—provided that you at your company, and my supplier, can build that other thing that doesn't exist yet."

For the participants, this isn't a scientific prediction but a promise—to friends, to partners. Someone thinks: "If we can't get this mirror right, the folks at ASML will be deeply disappointed." So everyone has to deliver, because everyone has already agreed to.

Moore's Law as collective hallucination and self-fulfilling prophecy

This perspective explains why Moore's Law has endured so long: it doesn't rely on some irrefutable physical constant but on the interlocking trust and pressure up and down the supply chain. If one link in the chain fails, the whole "law" starts to wobble.

Moore's Law was first proposed by Intel co-founder Gordon Moore in 1965, originally describing a doubling of transistors on an integrated circuit every year, later adjusted to roughly every two years. It wasn't derived from physical laws but was an observation of a historical trend. In the semiconductor industry, Moore's Law gradually evolved into a roadmap coordination mechanism—the International Technology Roadmap for Semiconductors (ITRS) and its successor IRDS are precisely the institutional embodiment of the industry collectively planning future technology nodes, with participants including equipment makers, materials suppliers, chip manufacturers, and research institutions.

Why Do Some People Hate Moore's Law?

The podcast noted that many in the industry are annoyed by Moore's Law's existence. The reasons aren't hard to understand: when a marketing slogan is treated as the industry's metronome, it turns around and holds everyone's expectations hostage.

Engineers and physicists face real-world material limits, lithography precision, heat dissipation, and cost issues—yet the outside world sums up all their work with a single phrase: "doubles every two years." This simplification isn't just inaccurate; it creates unrealistic schedule pressure.

The ASML physicist's attitude resonated precisely because he pierced that veil: Moore's Law is not a law of nature but an industry narrative told over and over again.

Everyone in the supply chain is promising something that doesn't exist

Lithography precision is one of the key bottlenecks determining whether Moore's Law can continue. Lithography machines transfer circuit patterns onto silicon wafers by exposing them to a light source, and resolution is limited by the light source's wavelength and numerical aperture. From deep ultraviolet (DUV) at 193nm to extreme ultraviolet (EUV) at 13.5nm, each wavelength reduction has come with enormous engineering investment and escalating costs. As processes approach physical limits, short-channel effects, quantum tunneling, and heat dissipation become increasingly prominent, making it harder and harder to rely solely on shrinking transistor dimensions—this is the technical root of Moore's Law's slowdown.

How Much Further Can a Self-Fulfilling Prophecy Go?

Understanding Moore's Law as a "self-fulfilling prophecy" is more explanatory than treating it as a physical law. The prophecy comes true because all key players act according to the same script—equipment makers, materials suppliers, chip design companies, and foundries lock each other in with promises.

This also means that when the technical difficulty becomes so great that some link in the chain can't deliver on its promise, the prophecy fails. It's not that a physical law has been overturned—it's that the rhythm of collective collaboration has been interrupted.

Promises between industry partners drive Moore's Law

For practitioners, a healthier stance might be: acknowledge Moore's Law's marketing component while understanding its practical role in coordinating a complex supply chain. It's neither a hoax nor an iron law, but a multi-party contract held together by trust and pressure.

Next time you see a headline saying "Moore's Law is dead" or "Moore's Law is still alive," it's worth asking first: whose promise went unfulfilled this time?

The concept of the "self-fulfilling prophecy" was proposed by sociologist Robert Merton, referring to an originally untrue expectation that comes true because people believe it and act accordingly. In the semiconductor industry, Moore's Law's survival depends on shared trust in the roadmap among all parties in the supply chain: equipment makers promise to deliver next-generation lithography machines, materials suppliers promise higher-purity chemicals, and foundries promise on-time mass production. Once a promise at any link can't be fulfilled, the entire chain of expectations loosens, and the prophecy may fail.

#Moore's Law#ASML#self-fulfilling prophecy#semiconductor supply chain#EUV lithography
Share:

Related articles