EACL
The European Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics, a top-tier NLP academic conference and part of the ACL conference series. It employs a peer-review process that includes a rebuttal phase and an Area Chair review system.
Core Facts
Timeline (last 90 days)
When committing an ARR paper to the EACL conference, the system requires uploading a PDF file while retaining the review link.
According to EACL conference rules, a paper's limitations should not be used as a weakness to deduct points.
In ACL-series conferences (including EACL), confidence is generally rated on a 1–5 scale, where 1–2 indicates the reviewer is unfamiliar with the field, and 5 indicates extremely high certainty.
One of the researcher's reviewers gave a low score of 2 but marked a high confidence of 5, and the criticism raised was one of the limitations already explicitly listed in the paper.
The researcher's other two reviews scored 3 and 4 respectively.
A researcher shared on the Reddit machine learning community their issue of receiving no response from a reviewer after submitting a rebuttal for their EACL submission.
ACL oversees multiple top conferences including the ACL Annual Meeting, EMNLP, NAACL, EACL, and AACL, as well as the Computational Linguistics journal and TACL
All Facts (5)
ACL Rolling Review (ARR) was officially launched in late 2021 as a systematic reform of the ACL paper review process for the NLP/CL field.
90%UnverifiedACL oversees multiple top conferences including the ACL Annual Meeting, EMNLP, NAACL, EACL, and AACL, as well as the Computational Linguistics journal and TACL
60%UnverifiedWhen committing an ARR paper to the EACL conference, the system requires uploading a PDF file while retaining the review link.
50%UnverifiedAccording to EACL conference rules, a paper's limitations should not be used as a weakness to deduct points.
50%UnverifiedIn ACL-series conferences (including EACL), confidence is generally rated on a 1–5 scale, where 1–2 indicates the reviewer is unfamiliar with the field, and 5 indicates extremely high certainty.
50%